The Problem With Gabriel
It looks like some straight-to-DVD loser when displayed in its poorly designed slip case on the shelves of your local rental store but Gabriel is actually a good deal more than your average C-list snoozefest.
Made for a tiny budget with a cast and crew who were happy to defer their own payment (which had it been necessary would have escalated production costs into the millions) Gabriel tells the story of a battle in purgatory between the seven Arcs (Archangels) and the seven Fallen. Purgatory is a city, Gabriel is an action hero, everyone wears trenchcoats and fires guns at one another (or if no ordnance is handy they kick and punch effectively). Many questions about this basic Manichean morality and metaphysics are toyed with. It’s not that it’s the deepest movie ever made, more it gets points for trying when no one else does.
I am not too surprised, however, by the fact that it leaves a lot of people cold. It’s the first time I’ve actually been able to point the finger and say “look what happens when you don’t give the script the attention it deserves”. The featurette that the distributors package on the DVD spends about thirty seconds talking about the script (and then it’s more about the “idea” for the “story” not the underlying mecanism of the script). If Back To The Future’s script is held up as an example of the absolute best in nuts and bolts script writing (apparently every line of dialogue in the film is purposeful in that it builds the story, no one says anything that doesn’t in some way contribute to some story task like signposting, foreshadowing, or paying off) then Gabriel’s script could be an example of what happens when you just want a script of some quality but you don’t really mind how much.
Don’t get me wrong the film is not horrible and the script is passing fair. However the number of loose ends and unresolved issues it leaves behind are a testament to just how happy the team were to get the thing made quickly, cheaply and how little understanding they had of just how important scripting could be.
Much aside from the fact that Gabriel polished off a demon in the blink of an eye with absolutely no feeling of moment or occasion (twenty minutes later he reeled the demon’s name off as one of those he’d already eliminated, even after that I had to retcon the actual incident from the featurette) there were more serious problems. One angel is reputed to have “lost their wings”. We don’t know how this condition comes to pass but apparently it’s permanent, serious, and completely changes the angel into a human (who’s dead in purgatory, but can ascend to heaven or descend to hell the same as a normal person). With no real explanation of how this could come to pass the punishment seems arbitrary, unrealistic and somewhat lacking in weight.
It reminds us that the only reason to write the nasty fate of someone who is not the main character is as a shadow or omen of the possible cost of failure to the current main character. Gabriel is an angel, and thus no more immune, apparently, to losing his wings than anyone else. The question remains, how does it happen? What does it entail? If we had details we could feel concern for the protagonist, without those mechanisms the threat is idle.
Gabriel informs us, through its several failures (which are not the sum of its parts, let’s not forget, much is done well, the rhythm of dialogue is good, clarity never an issue, and the subject matter is incredibly difficult so that’s a special boon in this case) of the mechanistic aspects of storytelling. Charlie Chaplin summarised the business of plot communication, to paraphrase: “Tell them you’re going to tell them something, tell them, and then tell them you’ve told them”.
If you’re a Nano contestant then the pressure to slap a bit more prose into the heap is paramount. I can understand that. Unfortunately it’s all the poor storytelling that comes back to bite you in the rear. Writing that perfect plot centres on a process of accruing story. Not assuming that people understand things.
Next time you’re writing a metaphysical action blockbuster and you blithely refer to an angel losing their wings, don’t just assume that people know how that happens or what it means. There could be a good couple of thousand words there in a satisfying explanation of the phenomenon.